Finally a Top 10 to be proud of...(it's still incomplete.  Haven't seen The Wrestler, Revolutionary Road, Frost/Nixon, Doubt, or The Reader...to name a few)

Anyway, here's the list as it stands now:

10. Transiberean

9. Tell No One

8. Slumdog Millionaire

7. The Wackness

6. In Search of a Midnight Kiss

5. Snow Angels

4. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button

3. The Dark Knight

2. Milk

1. WALL-E

and (for fun) the 5 worst:

5. Australia

4. The Happening

3. Cashback

2. Quantum of Solace

1. The Life Before Her Eyes